GEOS 24705 / ENST 24705. Energy: Science, Technology, and Human Usage
Prof: Liz Moyer
TA: Andrew Malone
Field trip coordinator: Javon Brown, Austin Herrick
Info (see documents below for more)
The course meets Tuesdays and Thursdays from 3:00-4:30 PM. There are two lab sessions each week; you can attend either one. Labs are Wednesday
3:30-4:30 PM or Thursday 1:30-2:30 PM
There are labs and field trips nearly every week but not all are mandatory. Course requirements include attendance at at least three field trips and at least four labs.
TA office hours will be in Hinds 425 or Hinds 451. Andrew is generously offering four different slots:
- Monday: 11:30 - 12:20
- Tuesday: 12:30 - 1:20
- Wednesday: 4:30 - 4:50
- Thursday: 12:30 - 1:20
The course description and instructions on requesting enrollment are
here
The syllabus (with tentative schedule of field trips and labs) is
here.
Photos are available from field trips in 2010 and 2011.
There is no textbook to purchase for this class, as there is no single book that is appropriate for the range of material and we don't want to ask you to buy several books. Instead we will assign readings to be done before certain lectures and will post those on this site in pdf form.
People coming in without college-level physics may want to prepare by reading the initial chapters of a book by Prof. David McKay of the University of Cambridge (U.K.) that is available for free
download in pdf format. (Renewable Energy: Without the Hot Air). For a broad perspective I also recommend any of the many books by Vaclav Smil (e.g. Energy at the Crossroads, Energy in World History, or Energy Transitions: History, Requirements, Prospects).
Lecture 1: Energy and wealth, energy flows on Earth
Energy / wealth relationship. Data: World Bank 1960-2011.
Lecture 1 slides.
Problem set 1. Due Friday April 3.
And answers.
Make-up classes for Friday April 3rd are offered at 11:30 AM or 1:30 PM, Hinds 451.
Lecture 2: Energy flows on Earth, energy requirements for human society
Earth's energy flows, Kiehl and Trenberth 1997
Lecture 2 slides
Problem set 2. Due Tuesday April 7.
And answers.
Lecture 3: Energy flows on Earth, agriculture
Fields in Oklahoma, Oklahoma Farm Report
Lecture 3 slides
Problem set 3. Due Thursday April 9.
And answers.
For those who are interested, here are some additional optional sources on the Green Revolution - a summary of land competition issues that includes future projections of land use if we are to feed 9B people (though be warned that the projections of future yield increases in the developed world are probably just speculation), and a discussion of questions about the counterproductive aspects of the Green Revolution. The FAO report cited in the Smith summary is online here.
Although we said in lecture that land use has been relatively flat for decades, land limitation seems to be an issue again, perhaps due to rising incomes as well as rising population. A student last year dug up some figures from the 2014 U.S. Farm Report showing the rise in recent decades in farmland prices, crop prices, farm incomes, and U.S. exports, suggestive of land scarcity in other countries. These are here. The complete report is here.
Lecture 4: Pre-industrial energy use and limitations
Hand-turned lathe, Diderot and d'Alembert, L'Encyclopedie, 1769-1772. Horse-drawn combine, U.S., 1910s-1920s.
Lecture 4 slides.
Required readings before Leture 5:
- Pre-Industrial-Revolution growth in human energy use (15th-18th centuries): the
chapter on energy
from "The Structures of Everyday Life", by the historian Fernand Braudel.
It is OK to skim the long and less relevant section on animal power. Pay especial attention to concluding remarks on p. 371-372.
- Selections from "A History of Coal Mining in Great Britain" by Robert Galloway. The book is available for download or online reading. Read Chapters I-III, the paragraph on London's dependence on coal in Chapter IV p. 35, Chapter VI, and Chapter VIII. The language is a bit Victorian but this book is an easy read and a great story. Notes: prices are given in pounds (l), shillings (s, 20 to a pound) and pence (d, 12 to a shilling or 240 to a pound). A "fathom" is 6 feet, or about 1.8 meters. The "noxious gases" or "fire-damp" in the coal mines (p. 26) are methane; methane is often associated with coal seams.
Problem set 4. Due Tuesday April 14.
And answers.
Lecture 5: Breaking the heat-to-work barrier - the steam engine
First commercial steam engine: Newcomen 1712.
Lecture 5 slides in pdf
and in
ppt
for those who want the animation.
Reading: For more background on steam engines, see this nice page on the history of steam engines set up by a professor from Michigan State.
Problem set 5. Due Thursday April 16.
And answers.
Field trip, Fri. April 17 Museum of Science and Industry for steam locomotives (also cogeneration and solar). Register for the trip at this link. (We have room for 20 people; register by Thursday morning and we'll let you know if you're in in class on Thursday). Meet outside the front doors of MOSI (north side of building) at 7:15 AM. Tour starts 7:30 AM but you will need to be signed in with the group.
Lecture 6: Steam engines, heat engines I
Left: From a 1781 patent application by Jonathan Hornblower for a compound steam engine (tied up in litigation with Watt).
Right: Animation of a double-acting steam engine powering a locomotive (standard arrangement from 1850s).
Lecture 6 slides in
pdf
and ppt.
Reading before Lecture 7:
Some readings about railroads and Chicago, and background about the fundamental theory behind heat-to-work, first laid out by Carnot, that we'll cover in class.
- Read the beginning of Chapter 2 ("Rails and Water") in Cronon's book on Chicago, Nature's Metropolis. Read from p. 55 to 76. You can skim, but read for a sense of what the railroads meant for the city and the U.S. in general. I'll post a scan later, but for now you can read this section via Google books here.
-
Read pages 105-119 of the chapter called "Engines and Refrigerators: the Second Law" from a great book called "The Refrigerator and the Universe". If everything is making a lot of sense, keep reading to 123. We'll cover this material in class on Tuesday. I'm posting the whole chapter in case people want to read further.
For optional additional reading, other options are:
- Carnot's original 1825 paper. A section from Carnot's "Reflections on the Motive Power of Fire and on Machines Fitted to Develop that Power". Pages 1-5 are very clear and worth reading by everyone, but read with decreasing focus as the paper goes on. Mostly make sure you understand all the sentences in bold-face (Carnot's original emphasis). When you read, remember that at the time Carnot is writing, in 1825, steam engines have been in existence for 125 years, in broad use for 50, and have been undergoing steady improvement, but no one has yet deduced the fundamental physics of how they work. Also note that Carnot still does not know what heat is; he thinks it is a fluid called "caloric". Which surprisingly, doesn't stand in his way at all of basically inventing engineering thermodynamics.
- A summary of Carnot's contributions, written
by a physicist.
- You may find my background notes on the physics of steam useful for some problems.
Problem set 6. Due Tuesday April 21.
And answers.
Lecture 7: Carnot efficiency limit continued.
Stages of the Carnot cycle
Lecture 7 slides (most material on blackboard).
Problem set 7. Due Thursday April 23.
And answers.
Reading before Lecture 8:
-
Read this summary of social effects of the Industrial Revolution and the growth of energy use, for Lecture 8, and skim some of the links.to primary-source readings (that is, things written at the time of the Industial Revolution). Read "1780-1800" and "The 19th Century".
- Read this handout on electricity and the basics of electrical generation - the whole thing if you haven't had physics lately, else just the history (Tesla vs. Edison). Also an 1882 New York Times
article
on the opening of Edison's first power plant in New York and the first lights in the New York Times building, and another
article 125 years later on the shut-down of the last DC power generation from Edison's original New York system.
Field trip, Fri. April 24 University of Chicago steam plant (campus heating and cooling). Register for the trip at this link. If more than 20 people sign up, we will try to schedule a second trip to accommodate everyone.
Meet 7:50 AM at the West Combined Utility Plant, 5615 South Maryland Ave. The entrance is located on the west elevation of the building. Tour starts 8:00 AM. Wear closed-toe shoes - no sandals.
Lecture 8: The Industrial Revolution and the transition to the modern energy system
Child workers in in the Bibb Mill in Macon, GA., between 1908-1912. Photo: Lewis Hine
Lecture 8 slides.
Problem set 8. Due Tuesday April 27. And the grid needed for Problem 4, and an example for Problem 4. Also a fuller version of that grid that includes some energy storage (not needed on this problem set). And answers.
Reading before Lecture 9: complete reading from previous lecture if not yet finished.
Lecture 9: Refrigeration, electricity I
L: First commercial refrigerator (driven by steam engine). Carre, 1859. R: Vapor-compression refrigeration cycle.
Problem set 9. Due Thursday April 30.
Lecture 10: Electricity II: DC and motors
(L): Simplest DC motor. (R): brushless DC motor.
Lecture 10 slides in pdf
and pptx.
Reading (esp. before this week's lab): this
reading
on electric motors.
Problem set 10. Due Tuesday May 4.
Lecture 11: Electricity III: AC and generation
660 MW generator, stator end windings.
Lecture 11 slides
Reading:
- This
description of the selection of technology for transmitting power from the Niagara Falls hydropower project. Note that options considered viable enough to bid for the contract include not only DC and AC electrical power but mechanical and hydraulic systems.
- Optional This
website giving pictures and descriptions of the first power transmission projects in the U.S., 1889-1909. (The site is by a group devoted to the electrical insulators use in high-voltage power lines.)
- A chapter from Brian Hayes' book "Infrastructure": Chapter 6: The Grid. Skim before Lecture 12 and read before the weekend's problem set.
Problem set 11. Due Thursday May 6.
Read these notes on final projects. You should form groups by next week, and send at least one representative from each group (ideally more) to Thursday's lab session to discuss your proposed question and get comments from others and approval or suggestions.
Lecture 12: Electricity IV: Generation and transmission
High-voltage transmission lines, from NordReg
Lecture 12 slides
Reading before Lecture 13: Three readings on turbines. Electricity is no longer made with reciprocating engines with pistons and cylinders. Instead, prime movers are now always turbines, cousins of the jet engine.
- The first part of the
power plants
chapter from "Infrastructure: A Field Guide to the Industrial Landscape". Read the
section on
fossil-fuel power plants, to page 201.
- A short letter from Nikola Tesla in 1892 describing his enthusiasm for new steam turbines that worked well for AC electricity generation and so would provide a further advantage to AC as a standard.
- Optional
A 1942 book about Sir Charles Parsons, the inventor of the steam turbine (in 1884).
Skim for historical context and great photos.
Problem set 12. Due Tuesday May 12.
Lecture 13: Power plants, turbines 1: steam and gas
Coal-fired power
plant, diagram from Tennesse Valley Authority.
Lecture 13 slides
Problem set 13. Due Thursday May 14 (extensions offered if this is too much for a Tuesday problem set).
Reading before Lecture 14:
Read the part of the Hayes
power plants
chapter on nuclear plants and hydro and wind turbines (p. 201-227).
Field trip, Wed. May 13 Repeat of U. Chicago steam plant trip, noon. Contact Andrew for further information.
Lecture 14: Turbines II: hydro
Inlet scroll of one of the Francis turbines of the Grand Coulee Dam, during construction.
Nuclear slides in pdf and pptx
Lecture 14 slides
Problem set 14. Due Tuesday May 19.
Readings (optional):
-
A nice review of wind turbines and wind turbine control.
Some brief notes on rotational vs. linear velocity, if you need review for the problem set.
- The 2013 Wind Technologies Market Report from Lawrence Berkeley lab (80+ pages but full of good information).
Field trip, Fri. May 15 Dresden Nuclear Generating Station. Attendance limited. Sign up here. Non-GEOS24705 Harris students sign up here. Attendance is limited; sign-up is first come first serve. If you get on the trip, you will have to provide your SSN (and passport/visa information, if international) by May 8th; bring to class on paper or email to Liz or Andrew or make other arrangements to provide it. Trip meets 6:15 AM on 57th St. in front of Regenstein; bus leaves at 6:30 AM. Bring photo ID, passport if international. Wear flat closed-to shoes, long-sleeve shirts. Tour will finish around lunchtime and lunch is usually provided on site. Bus returns for afternoon classes (aim for 1 PM return). No photography.
Lecture 15: Turbines III: wind
Turbulence behind offshore wind turbines at Horns Rev 1, Denmark (image: Christian Steiness)
Lecture 15 slides.
For the discussion about electricity markets on Thursday 1:30 PM, some slides with background.
Lecture 16: Internal combustion engines / transportation
Gas- or petrol-powered car, Karl Benz, 1886.
Reading: The auto industry began with a period of experimentation and innovation, then had a century of relative stasis - and now is seeing a new wave of innovation. It's an interesting time. Read this 1959 Harper's
article
on the virtues of steam for automobiles, which has some advantages over internal combustion, and could still make a comeback, and then read this 2001 article about a new high-tech steam engine for cars developed by a company called Enginion AG. (Innovation still includes the old companies: Enginion AG is a spin-off from Volkswagen, which started with Porsche designs and is now merged with Porsche). The recent burst of innovation includes work on the internal combustion engine, which is being re-thought. Here is a fairly simple popular article from CNN and a more detailed (but jargon-y) article from Car & Driver.
Lecture 16 slides in pdf and also in
ppt so you can see the animations.
Problem set 16. Due Tuesday May 26.
Field trip, Fri. May 22 Advanced Auto Lab at Argonne National Laboratory. Sign up here and fill out Argonne visitor information form. Meet at 6:40 AM in front of Regenstein; trip begins at 8 AM but there is a security step to get through. Return to campus approximately 12:30 PM. U.S. citizens bring driver's license or equivalent information; foreign citizens bring passport (and any separate visa information if relevant).
Lecture 17: Internal combustion engines and transportation II
Otto cycle
Lecture 17
slides.
Problem set 17. Due Thursday May 28.
Lecture 18: Internal combustion engines and transportation III, fossil fuels I
![Prius engine](../Images/PriusEngine.jpg)
Prius Hybrid Synergy Drive (gasoline engine + electric motor)
Lecture 18 slides.
Reading: read the oil & gas
chapter of the Hayes book.
Problem set 18. The solar costs report needed to do problem 3 is here. Due Tuesday June 2. Optional problem #4 is strongly recommended.
Lecture 19: Fossil fuels II, solar PV and solar thermal
![Fracking for gas.](../Images/fracking.jpg)
L: Alberta oil sands. Image: David Dodge / Pembina Inst.
R: Conventional drilling vs. hydraulic fracturing for gas.
Lecture 19 slides.
Solar photovoltaic notes for this week's lab.
Field trip, Th. June 4 Buildings: Loyola University sustainability center. Sign up here. Trip will be 3-4 PM, departure from U. Chicago 2:15 PM Hinds lobby.
Field trip, Fri. June 5 Pleasant Prairie Power Plant (coal-fired generation, also with demonstration CO2 separation and advanced air quality system). Sign up here. Bus departure time = 7:15 AM. 1.5 hour drive time. Tour returns by 1 PM. Wear flat closed-toe shoes, long pants, shirts with sleeves. No photography.
Copyright E. Moyer 2015